The plan grows a short brief into six milestones #308

Closed
opened 2026-10-29 15:32:32 -04:00 by cmoriarty · 1 comment
Owner

What happens
The Breakout brief asked for the game, three lives, score, sounds, and play on a phone. The plan step made six milestones: Now (the game, then sounds), Next "More than one game", and four Later milestones the brief never asked for: power-ups, two players, an installable app, sharing a score. Run to completion, that is up to 18 runs at ~3 h each.

Fix
The plan covers what the brief asks; ideas beyond it go in a short "Could add" list for the operator, not into Next or Later.

Done when
The same brief plans to at most the milestones the brief needs (one or two), with any extras listed apart.

From the Breakout project (run 138's plan).

**What happens** The Breakout brief asked for the game, three lives, score, sounds, and play on a phone. The plan step made six milestones: Now (the game, then sounds), Next "More than one game", and four Later milestones the brief never asked for: power-ups, two players, an installable app, sharing a score. Run to completion, that is up to 18 runs at ~3 h each. **Fix** The plan covers what the brief asks; ideas beyond it go in a short "Could add" list for the operator, not into Next or Later. **Done when** The same brief plans to at most the milestones the brief needs (one or two), with any extras listed apart. _From the Breakout project (run 138's plan)._
Author
Owner

Confirmed on production (6f440e5, PR #310); closing.

The same Breakout brief that run 139 (run 138's plan) grew into six milestones now gives one. Run 146's PLAN.md:

  • Now: the whole game. One item, add-breakout-game, done when a person plays a full game on a phone and a desktop, with every control and sound, wins or loses, and starts again.
  • No Next or Later. The brief asks for neither.
  • Assumptions: the look, the sounds made in code, touch control.
  • Could add, five ideas of the agent's own: a lasting high score, power-ups, more levels, a mute button, pausing when the window loses focus.

The project page reads milestone 1 of 1, with 0 of 1 items done.

**Confirmed on production (6f440e5, PR #310); closing.** The same Breakout brief that run 139 (run 138's plan) grew into six milestones now gives one. Run 146's `PLAN.md`: - **Now: the whole game.** One item, `add-breakout-game`, done when a person plays a full game on a phone and a desktop, with every control and sound, wins or loses, and starts again. - **No Next or Later.** The brief asks for neither. - **Assumptions**: the look, the sounds made in code, touch control. - **Could add**, five ideas of the agent's own: a lasting high score, power-ups, more levels, a mute button, pausing when the window loses focus. The project page reads milestone 1 of 1, with 0 of 1 items done.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No labels
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set

Reference
cmoriarty/braid#308
No description provided.