A respawn or compaction hands over tool names, not evidence: judges redo passed checks, and a judge that went idle without its report loses 27 min #383
Loading…
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "%!s()"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
What happens
Run 172 had five context alarms (apply 08:12 and 08:56, visual-check.r2, fix.r2, visual-check.r3). Braid's handoff note names the files and tool calls but not the subagent reports or the criteria already judged, so:
store.tsread 7x,App.tsx4x over the run).Separately, r3 attempt 1 said "Every screen verified. Writing the round-3 report." and went idle without the write; the predicate failed it (
judge.json is missing or empty, 14:48:58) and attempt 2 re-judged from scratch: 27 min lost. Neither r3 attempt wrote thefinished: falsestub the brief asks for, so the respawn had nothing to carry.Fix
.osf/fix/rN/checks/as it arrives, so a respawn, a fork and the next round all read them.subagentcall of a judge untiljudge.jsonexists withfinished: false.Done when
A respawned judge does not re-run a check its subagents already reported, a lost report cannot pass a round, and a judge that forgets the write is nudged rather than discarded. ~50 + 27 min on run 172.
From the run 172 transcript review (Scratch on vLLM + MTP k=4, 2026-11-04; report in the owner's
~/repos/vLLM/reports/). Related: braid#378, braid#379.Shipped in PR #390, production
ddd4b6b.Measured on run 172: forks started at 81.7k (apply), 159.6k (round 2), 178.7k (second fix round), and 138.7k and 142.2k (round 3), against a 196k alarm. A fresh session starts at about 24k to 26k, brief included. The first fix round's fork got a 404 on a session whose worktree had gone.
Evidence:
tests/engine/test_fork_room.py(failed first),test_note_reports.py,test_ask_for_report.py, and simsfork-leaves-no-roomandjudge-forgets-report. Scripted replays of rounds 2 and 3: the ask fires where round 3 went idle.Not proved: speed on vLLM, since trogdor was busy.
unclearcontradiction, each judge writing its own validator, reviewers re-reading pasted text #386