An operator's words at a review gate never reach the agent: the Review lens sends them as text, and decisions.md is written from the labels only #182
Loading…
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "%!s()"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Found on run 67, the solo verification run (production
74e261c, 2026-10-16). Atsolo's proposal gate the operator answered Request changes and said what to change. The revise step's brief read "## What they said … (no words were given)", so it changed nothing and committed only.osf/decisions.md.Why
ui/src/components/Review.tsxsends the decision asanswers: [[label]]and the operator's words intext.decisions.md:osf.engine.decisionswrites the gate's section from the question and the answer labels only;textisn't written anywhere an agent reads.build_propose_revise_solotakes the words from answer labels other than "Request changes", which the Review lens never sends.GateCardmakes the operator choose either an option or their own words, since typing replaces the selection. Words alone are classedunknown, not a request for changes, so no revise runs.So from the console, a person can't send a proposal back with what is wrong. The same loss hits
thorough's "Approve with edits" ("say below what you want changed"): its words never reach apply.The rest works. With the words sent as a second answer label,
openspec.revise.solo.r2got them verbatim and revised the proposal, spec, design and tasks as asked, in 7.1 min.Wanted
textis written into itsdecisions.mdsection, as "The operator's words: …", and read by the revise brief and by apply.[[label]]plustext) to the revise brief containing the words.Related: #176 (thorough's Request changes sends nothing back), #151.
Shipped in
bb5d87a(changegate-words-reach-the-agent, commitd5ea170), live since 00:07Z on 2026-10-17, and archived in2f7d842.gate.answer_text(schema 14)..osf/decisions.mdends with "The operator's words:" and the words quoted, so apply, the revise steps and every brief that reads the file have them.run_01M53R7621CJW6PCZG7S6R94HS, thorough on cmoriarty/braid-combined-test, vLLM). The proposal gate was answered Request changes, with words sent as the Review lens sends them.decisions.mdquoted the words, and agent.revise.operator's brief had them under "What they said".decisions.md, the revise briefs, a browser spec for the card, and the simulated runthorough-request-changes.Closing.